A Painted Tale

A fair comparison

Games like A Painted Tale, and how it differs from each

If you loved one of the four games below, this page says honestly what A Painted Tale shares with it and where it parts ways. It is smaller than all of them, it is not out yet, and it is like each in one clear way.

In one sentence: A Painted Tale is a single-player, first-person fantasy adventure in which a knight walks one long valley to a castle, and everything on screen is a stroke of paint. It is calm for most of its length and it has real fights in it.

The five games on the same questions
GameViewPaceCombatLookGoal
A Painted TaleFirst personUnhurried walk along one roadYes: sword, torch and dodge against a few kinds of foeBrush strokes pinned to a 3D worldA castle in sight from the first step
EastshadeFirst personUnhurried, open island to exploreNoneLush, painterly 3DPaint pictures of places for the people you meet
JourneyThird personA short, flowing pilgrimageNoneSpare, stylised desertA mountain in sight from the start
11-11 Memories RetoldThird personStory-ledNone to fight yourselfThe whole picture in moving brush strokesTwo men’s stories in the Great War
Shadow of the ColossusThird personLong rides, then a great fightOnly the colossiMuted, vast and emptySixteen giants, to bring someone back

If you liked Eastshade

Alike: you walk through a beautiful land in first person, at your own pace, and you talk to the people in it. Both games are about looking. Eastshade makes you a painter; A Painted Tale makes the world itself the painting.

Different: Eastshade has no combat and an open island. A Painted Tale has one road with a direction, a sword in your hand, and things on the road that will hurt you. It is also far shorter on things to do: there is one inn, not a town of quests.

If you liked Journey

Alike: the goal is in the picture from the first moment and you walk toward it the whole way. In Journey it is a mountain; here it is a castle on a crag, six kilometres off at sunrise and overhead by night. In both, the light and the land change as you go, and that change is the story’s pulse.

Different: Journey is wordless, third-person and shared with a stranger. A Painted Tale is first-person, alone, and has words: an innkeeper and a village boy who talk, quests on a scroll, a teller who takes the tale back when it goes wrong. And it has combat, which Journey does not.

A painted valley at sunrise. A path of warm ochre strokes runs through grass and small flowers toward dark firs and low mist; far ahead a black castle stands on a crag between pale, snowy peaks under a yellow sky.
The first step of the game. The castle is six kilometres off and already in sight.

If you liked 11-11 Memories Retold

Alike: the look. 11-11 Memories Retold is the best-known game drawn wholly in living brush strokes, and anyone who was struck by it will see the kinship at once.

Different: the two games paint differently. In A Painted Tale every stroke is pinned to its place in the world and stays there: a leaf is the same stroke from every side, and nothing is treated on the screen afterwards. How the valley is painted explains it. The subject differs just as much: 11-11 is a story of the First World War; this is a knight, a princess and a wolf called Rimefang.

If you liked Shadow of the Colossus

Alike: a lone figure in a quiet land, long stretches with nothing to fight, and then something very large. The Moss Golem of Summer’s Vale stands three and a half metres tall, and the stillness before it is part of meeting it.

Different: scale, above all. A colossus is a mountain you climb; the golem is a giant you face on the ground. A Painted Tale has a village, seasons and smaller foes along one road, where Shadow of the Colossus has an empty land and sixteen fights. It does not try to be that game.

Who A Painted Tale is for

It is probably not for you if you want no combat at all, a large open world, or dozens of hours of quests. The questions page answers the rest, and the tale so far says what is in the game today.

Eastshade, Journey, 11-11 Memories Retold and Shadow of the Colossus are the work and the trademarks of their own makers. A Painted Tale has no tie to any of them; they are named here only to compare.