A Painted Tale

Devlog · 19 November 2026

Why no leaf spins

Brush strokes that face the viewer turn as you walk under a tree. How A Painted Tale keeps every leaf, bough and cloud still, and the rule that came out of it.

A path through an autumn wood in low light: bushes and trees in red, orange and gold strokes, dark leaf litter, a violet sky between the slopes.
Halfway. The sun is going down behind you, and the leaves with it.

A stroke in A Painted Tale is a small card with one mark of a brush on it. The simplest way to draw such a card is to turn it to face the viewer. It is also the way that ruins a painting the moment you move: walk in under a tree, look up, and every leaf swings round to keep facing you. The crown seems to stir when there is no wind. Paint on a canvas does not do that.

What a stroke may know

The cure began as a rule about what a stroke is allowed to know. The way a stroke runs on the canvas may depend on where it is pinned and how it lies in the world. Nothing of the camera may be in it: no angle taken by chance, and no height or distance at which a stroke is suddenly drawn another way. Each of those was tried, and each made strokes spin somewhere.

Two ways to lie still

Strokes are taken one of two ways.

Bark, the boughs of a fir and blades of grass are drawn as they would be seen from the eye’s own height. A bough that hangs keeps hanging however near you come, and a level stroke that points at you lies level.

Leaves and clouds are stiffer. A leaf is drawn as it lies in the world, exactly as long as it is seen. Its two ends stay where they are, so a leaf seen end on shrinks to a speck where it would otherwise turn broadside. No leaf turns but as its tree does.

Wood is sticks

Branches needed a third thing. The strokes of a limb are laid end to end along one line. Treated as strokes that hang, each one left the limb’s line when seen from below and swung back onto it under the tree: a bough came apart as you walked beneath. So the wood of every tree that has branches is laid as rigid sticks, fixed along the limb. A thread of a spider’s web is laid the same way.

Clouds were the hardest

A cloud passes overhead, which no tree does. Its strokes were tried lying level while low in the sky, and lying as the cloud’s sheet lies when overhead. Every one of them turned at some point on the way over. They are now fixed to their cloud and never turn against it.

The game has a check that looks for strokes that spin, and it is run after every change to the painter. How the valley is painted has the rest of the method.

All notes from the making